Picture a $90 million distributor that rolled out an AI assistant to 150 office staff last spring. The bill was flat and dull: a fixed price per person, budgeted once by the CFO. At renewal, the same tool comes back with a new setting switched on. On top of the fixed price, each person’s use is now metered. Nobody in the executive meeting remembers deciding that. The first sign is an invoice that does not match the budget. (This is an illustration, not a client.)
Nobody in the executive meeting remembers deciding that.
Earlier this month we asked what belongs in next year’s technology budget, in Before You Approve Next Year’s IT Budget. This is a sequel about one line that may stop being fixed: AI tools that bill by use. The decision is not technical. It is about who is allowed to spend your money, and who notices.
What Is Changing, and When?
On November 3, Microsoft told its resellers that usage-based billing will be turned on by default for new Microsoft 365 Copilot Business purchases made through its partner channel during January through March 2027, per its partner announcement. It had earlier said December 1. The default spending limit is 4,000 Copilot Credits per person per month, and administrators can change it. Microsoft’s own example is a company with 100 users that could use up to 400,000 credits a month under the default, billed on actual use. The announcement adds that disabling usage-based billing might limit access to AI experiences, and that a new purchase turns the setting on by default for existing Copilot Business licenses in the same tenant.
The page gives no dollar rate per credit, so we cannot tell you what 400,000 credits costs. Your reseller can, and you should ask for the number in writing. Two limits on what we are claiming. This is one vendor and one product, sold through resellers, so it may not describe your contract. We use it because it is dated, in writing, and an early example of a pattern: AI features priced by what people use instead of by seat. In our view more vendors will follow, so the sensible move is to ask every AI vendor the same questions.
Why Does This Land on the CEO’s Desk?
A flat per-person price is a budget line. A usage price is a variable cost that behaves like a utility bill, and two things control it that nobody has been assigned: a setting and a habit. The setting is the spending limit. The habit is how often 150 people choose to use a tool that now has a meter. Set the limit too high and the bill surprises your CFO. Set it too low, or switch the feature off, and the people you bought it for may lose the very thing that was saving them time. That is a trade between cost and benefit, and the CEO owns trade-offs of that kind. If no one is named, the default decides, and the vendor wrote the default.
If no one is named, the default decides, and the vendor wrote the default.
How Common Are Surprise Charges Already?
In January 2026 the software-spend firm Zylo published a survey of 218 IT leaders. It reported that 78 percent had seen unexpected charges tied to consumption-based or AI pricing in the prior twelve months, and that 61 percent had been forced to cut projects because of unplanned software cost increases (Zylo 2026 SaaS Management Index). Read it with care. Zylo sells software spend management, the sample is small and self-reported, and it is not limited to midsize companies. Even so, it tells you two things worth planning around: surprise charges are common, and the cost of being surprised is often a cancelled project, not just a larger invoice.
Is This Only About One Vendor’s AI Tool?
No, and that is the larger point. Software prices are moving on two tracks at once. The first is the list price. Microsoft raised list prices on most Microsoft 365 business plans on July 1, 2026, for example Business Standard from $12.50 to $14 per user per month, and its notice says existing customers stay on current pricing until renewal (Microsoft’s own price notice). The second track is the way the meter is read: by seat, by use, or by bundle. A company can see a flat bill at one renewal and a variable one at the next, with no one in the room having chosen the change.
That is why we suggest treating the renewal calendar as a CEO document, not an IT file. Every renewal is a moment when a vendor may change the price, the unit being priced, or the default settings, and each of those can move your budget.
What Three Decisions Should You Make Before the Switch Flips?
First, name one owner for AI spending. Not the IT team by default and not whoever signed the contract, but one person who sees the monthly number and answers for it to you. In most midsize companies that is the CFO or the controller, with the IT lead supplying the facts.
Second, set a monthly ceiling you can defend, in dollars, and decide in advance what happens as usage nears it. Picture a ceiling of $5,000 a month across those 150 people. That is about $33 per person, a number invented for this illustration. The figure matters less than the fact that someone chose it, and that you decided ahead of time whether reaching 80 percent triggers a message to the owner, a pause, or an approved exception.
Third, decide what result the spending must show. Spend with no result attached is a cost. Spend tied to hours saved, orders handled or revenue closed is an investment you can defend to a board. Our judgment is that a usage meter is the best thing to happen to AI return on investment, because it forces the question every flat fee let you avoid: what did we get for it? Our pieces on AI uses that sell and on what boards want to see on AI show what a defensible answer looks like. Rebuilding the budget row by row, as we describe in If Your Tech Budget Looks Like Last Year’s, is the natural place to put the new line.
What Do You Tell Your Board and Your Lender?
Boards and lenders rarely ask about a spending limit. They ask whether management knows where the money goes and who is accountable for it. A short, true answer is enough: we know which AI tools bill by use, one named person owns the monthly number, we set a ceiling in dollars, and we review what the spending delivered each quarter. Your auditors and insurers may ask a similar question about control over who can do what with company data, so the same owner and the same written list will serve both. Write it down once, date it, and keep it where the CFO can find it.
What Should You Ask Your IT Lead and Your Reseller?
Put these in plain words and ask for written answers in dollars by the end of the month. Is any of our AI software billed by use, now or at the next renewal? What is the default limit, who can change it, and what does it cost us at that limit in a month? Will someone be warned before we reach it, and who? Can limits be set by department? When does each contract renew, and how much notice must we give? At the last renewal, which vendors changed their terms, and did anyone read the change? If the answer to any of these is a shrug, you have found the first gap.
If the answer to any of these is a shrug, you have found the first gap.
What This Will Not Do
A spending limit does not tell you whether a tool is worth buying. It does not cover the AI features that arrive inside software you already own from other vendors, each with its own terms. And it does not replace reading your own agreement. This article summarizes one vendor’s announcement to its resellers, not your contract, and prices and dates can change. This is not legal advice.
Where to Start
This week, ask your IT lead one question: which of our AI tools will bill by use, and what is the most each could cost us in a month? Then name the owner. If you want an outside check, our CIO IQ service gives you an experienced CIO’s review at $1k per week, and our IT and AI assessment maps what renews, on what terms, and what it is delivering. You can also reach us through the contact form on our About page.


