U.S. Cyber Insurance Stopped Getting Cheaper · What’s Negotiable?

U.S. cyber insurance rates finally stopped falling, but claims keep rising. We walk through what insurers now treat as standard, two real cases where MFA misstatements voided coverage, where mid-market claims actually fall short, what you can still negotiate, and how mature IT earns credit at renewal.
Two managers seen from behind at a railing overlook a busy factory floor at golden hour beneath a glowing blue hexagonal dome with a few panels missing.

On October 21, Marsh reported that U.S. cyber insurance rates were flat in the third quarter, after an extended stretch of declines. Global rates kept falling, down 4% for a 13th straight quarterly decrease, and the broker said many buyers were using the extra capacity to broaden coverage and lower retentions. If your policy renews on January 1, you have about six weeks to do the same.

Our view is that this renewal deserves more executive attention than the last three. Price has been the easy win. Terms are the win still on the table, and terms decide whether a claim gets paid.

Price has been the easy win. Terms are the win still on the table, and terms decide whether a claim gets paid.

This piece covers what insurers now treat as standard, where mid-market claims fall short, what you can negotiate, what you cannot, and how to get credit for the security work you have already paid for.

 

What the Market Is Telling You

A flat quarter is not a hard market. The 2027 outlook from the broker WTW, published October 1, predicts cyber rates somewhere between a 5% decrease and a 5% increase, and notes that moderation is appearing at some insurers. Meanwhile the claims keep coming. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners reported in October that claims reported to U.S. cyber insurers rose 20% in 2025, to 56,323. Falling prices and rising claims do not travel together forever. Our judgment is that you should use this renewal to lock in better wording while insurers still compete for the account, rather than chase one more discount.

 

What Has Become Standard

Start with the controls. Marsh lists 12 that it says insurers scrutinize, some as minimum requirements: multifactor authentication (MFA) for remote and administrator access, email filtering, tested backups, privileged access management, endpoint detection and response (EDR), patching, an incident response plan, security awareness training, hardened remote access, logging and monitoring, replacement or protection of out-of-support systems, and oversight of technology vendors. A September alert from the law firm Shumaker treats a similar list as non-negotiable and adds that insurers increasingly view text-message codes as inadequate MFA. If you still run Windows Server 2016, which loses patches on January 12, expect a question about it.

The policy has a standard shape too. Liability coverage is typically claims-made, so late notice can cost you coverage. Most insurers expect you to use their approved lawyers and forensic firms. Business interruption coverage usually begins after a waiting period, commonly 6 to 24 hours according to an August review in Agency Checklists. And the limit on the first page is rarely the limit that applies to every kind of loss.

 

The Application Is a Signed Statement

The questionnaire is no longer paperwork. In 2022, Travelers asked a federal court in Illinois to void a policy after ransomware hit an electronics manufacturer. The application said MFA protected administrative access, and the company’s president had signed an MFA attestation. Investigators found it only on the firewall. Within two months the company agreed to rescission, which treats the policy as if it never existed.

In February 2024, ransomware hit the City of Hamilton, Ontario. On July 30, 2025, the city disclosed in a staff briefing that its insurer had denied the claim because multi-factor authentication had not been fully implemented at the time of the attack, consistent with a coverage exclusion, and that the response had by then cost about C$18.3 million. Canadian news reports said a third-party review preceded the decision not to pursue the matter further.

Intent may not matter. Lawyers at Hunton Andrews Kurth, who represent policyholders, have warned that in many jurisdictions even an unintentional misstatement can void coverage. So answer each question for the specific system it covers, write down the exceptions, and have the person who runs that system confirm the answer before an officer signs.

 

Where the Money Is Actually Lost

Ransomware gets the headlines, but fraud fills the claims file. Coalition, reporting in March on its own book of more than 100,000 policyholders, said business email compromise and funds transfer fraud made up 58% of 2025 claims, with an average funds transfer loss of $141,000. That matters because fraud coverage is usually capped far below the policy limit. Hunton’s lawyers wrote in June that cyber policies often cap it at $250,000 or less, and often pay only if staff confirmed the payment change through a separate channel. Crime policies carry similar caps, the same lawyers note, so check how the two fit together before you assume one covers what the other does not.

Speed matters too. At-Bay, another insurer, recovered at least some of the stolen money 70% of the time when it heard within three days. Put the insurer’s claims line at the top of your response plan. The fraud itself keeps getting more convincing, as we described in our piece on AI-driven closing fraud.

The second gap is downtime. The same At-Bay review of its own claims found that one in three ransomware claims in 2025 triggered business interruption coverage, and those claims averaged $510,000 against $168,000 for the rest. Then there is downtime that starts at a vendor. Megan North of the wholesale broker Amwins told Insurance Business in October that carriers are adding sublimits for outages at outside technology providers. Her summary: “Outsourcing the function doesn’t outsource the risk.”

Outsourcing the function doesn’t outsource the risk.

Picture a $60 million distributor with a $3 million policy. A $250,000 fraud cap, a 12-hour waiting period and a $250,000 cap on vendor outages mean its three most likely claims never come near $3 million. The company and its figures are illustrative.

 

What You Can Negotiate

More than most buyers ask for. Marsh McLennan Agency, WTW and Hunton offer overlapping lists: limits, retentions, sublimits, waiting periods and, in Hunton’s case, coinsurance and vendor panels. Ask for a higher fraud cap, and learn exactly which verification steps the policy requires. Ask for a shorter waiting period and a restoration period that matches how long recovery would really take. If nobody has costed a week of downtime, start with the budget questions we suggested for CEOs. Ask whether vendor outages are covered at the full limit, whether that includes outages with no attacker involved, and what it costs to raise the cap.

Vendors are negotiable before a loss and rarely after. If you already have breach counsel or an incident response firm, Hunton advises getting them approved by endorsement. If you change insurers, carry your retroactive date over so an intrusion that began under the old policy is still covered. Marsh says more long-term agreements were achievable across commercial lines last quarter, so ask whether a multi-year deal is available.

Two newer items belong on the list. Ask how the policy treats privacy claims that involve no breach at all, such as lawsuits over website tracking. Marsh’s U.S. commentary says those claims are rising, and WTW notes that the wording varies widely between insurers. Then read any artificial intelligence (AI) endorsement. Marsh notes that some insurers have introduced them as enhancements, while WTW says most cyber policies still do not single AI out. Whether the wording helps depends on how you use AI.

 

What You Cannot

You cannot negotiate around the controls. Our view is that a disclosed gap with a plan and a date is a negotiation, and a wrong answer is a liability. You cannot soften the application itself, because the accuracy of your answers is what the contract rests on.

You cannot soften the application itself, because the accuracy of your answers is what the contract rests on.

You cannot remove the war exclusion. Lloyd’s has required standalone cyber policies in its market to exclude war and the most damaging state-backed attacks since March 31, 2023, and most other carriers have their own versions, although the wording differs enough to be worth comparing. Do not expect to waive notice deadlines or the insurer’s say over costs before you spend. And our judgment is that no carrier will take unlimited exposure to one cloud provider failing for everyone at once.

 

Getting Credit for Mature IT

This is where a well-run technology shop earns something back. Insurers do not only read your answers. Coalition says it scans its policyholders’ internet-facing systems monthly and that unresolved findings can complicate renewal. The wholesale broker CRC Group noted in 2022 that these scans shape underwriting decisions and are sometimes wrong. Ask your broker what the insurer’s scan shows before you submit, fix what is real, and dispute what is not. Look hardest at remote access. At-Bay traced 73% of the ransomware attacks in its 2025 claims to VPNs.

Then replace yes and no with evidence. A Marsh McLennan analysis that compared clients’ security self-assessments with claims, published in August 2025, found that each 25-point increase in EDR coverage across laptops and workstations was associated with a further 10% drop in breach likelihood, that organizations running regular tabletop exercises were 13% less likely to have a material event, and that phishing-resistant MFA was associated with 9% lower breach likelihood than ordinary MFA. Those are correlations in one broker’s data, not guarantees. They still show what an underwriter wants to see: coverage percentages, test dates, and exceptions with deadlines. Send a one-page summary with the application and ask for a call with the underwriter.

We have seen it pay. At a private university where we provided a virtual CIO, an outside security rating rose from 630 to 740 and the cyber insurance premium came down. We did not publish the size of that reduction, and one case is not a rate schedule. Our view is that evidence buys better terms more reliably than it buys a lower price.

 

What This Will Not Do

This is not legal or insurance advice. Policy forms differ by insurer and change at renewal, so your own wording governs, and your broker and coverage counsel should review it. The claims figures come from individual insurers’ own books and may not match your size or industry. The Marsh findings are correlations. The Travelers and Hamilton matters each turned on their own facts and policies. Strong controls do not guarantee a paid claim, and nothing here predicts what an insurer will quote you. Market data reflects public reports as of mid-November 2026.

 

Where to Start

This week, pull the application you signed last year. Give each security question to the person who runs that system and ask for three things: the true answer today, the evidence, and the exceptions. That one exercise shows you what to fix, what to disclose, and what to take credit for. Next year, start several months ahead and put finance, legal and IT in the same room, as Hunton recommends. If you would like a second set of eyes, our assessments cover security posture as part of a three-week review, an experienced CIO through CIO IQ can walk the application with your team at $1k per week, and our cybersecurity practice can help close the gaps. Reach us through the contact form on our About page.

More from our blog

Your AI Dividend Can Fund a Reputation · A Role-Model Layoff

Your AI Dividend Can Fund a Reputation · A Role-Model Layoff

An AI-driven layoff can be announced like any other, or funded differently, with the savings paying for a real bridge…
U.S. Cyber Insurance Stopped Getting Cheaper · What's Negotiable?

U.S. Cyber Insurance Stopped Getting Cheaper · What's Negotiable?

U.S. cyber insurance rates finally stopped falling, but claims keep rising. We walk through what insurers now treat as standard,…
Who Owns the Modem on Your Well Pad? · The Cyber Gap Between IT and Field Operations

Who Owns the Modem on Your Well Pad? · The Cyber Gap Between IT and Field Operations

Many mid-market oil and gas operators split technology between IT in the office and operations in the field, and the…